We had made it a few days without making any new purchases when our first misfortune struck. While doing laundry, I accidentally split bleach on my jeans. Usually I would say “eh, I’ll wear them with the bleach stain”. But these had been the nice jeans I wear to work. While my professional job doesn’t really have a dress code, I would be a bit embarrassed to show up in stained jeans. I guess I should get a new pair.

Our haul (Before trying everything on)
Jeans are a tricky thing. Most females I know have spent years finding a set brand/style of jeans that they feel is the best fit for them. Since years ago in grad school when I concluded I could no longer wear the low cut jeans that show off my no-longer as firm belly, I have been wearing Banana Republic Classic fit jeans. For some reason, this cut fits me well and is loose and tight in all the right places. I was tempted just to hop on eBay and immediately look for Banana Republic Classic Fit jeans there were used, but, as per our rules of this experiment, I decided to hit some of our local thrift shops first. My husband and I headed to the local Salvation Army. I warned him ahead of time this one could take a while. I knew my size and cut so well with Banana Republic, and I had no idea where to begin with other brands.
All the jeans were just thrown onto several very large racks, with no division by size. Groan! It took forever to look through them all. I was pretty amused by the large variety of brands though. I found everything from Wal-Mart brand and Old Navy all the way to a pair of True Religion jeans (not in my size unfortunately). So I started trying on. I headed to the dressing room with a cart filled to the brim with jeans. I had no idea where to begin. I soon learned that sizes mean nothing. While I had long been a 6 in Banana Republic, I discovered I was an 8 in Ann Taylor and a 10 in Lee. What the hell? I also discovered that though I look at jeans as a permanent staple of fashion, the style of jeans have changed a great deal throughout the decades, and all decades were shoved onto these racks. I tried on plenty of 80′s jeans with harsh acid washes and zippers at the base. I tried some totally 90′s jeans that had extreme boot cut and rhinestones adorning the pockets.

Two bags for under $100
My last big discovery of used jean shopping was regarding the time frame. I shopped for used jeans in mid November. Over 50% of what I found on the racks were cropped style jeans obviously donated just after summer ended. But I did find a lot of cropped (Capri) jeans that fit well. So this winter I’m allowing the used jean shopping trip to dictate my fashion sense. I think I can wear a pair of cropped jeans with boots and still have it look cute; a nice fashion statement that reflects the limited stock of full-length used jeans.
Now for the upside of the trip, usually I would pay around $90 a pair for Banana Republic jeans. Plus I would usually get two pairs at a time in different color shades. So regularly I could spend about $200 just to get two pairs of jeans. I saved a bundle by getting them at the Goodwill, but it did take me over an hour to find a few pairs, as opposed to just walking in a Banana Republic and being done in five minutes.
So, in conclusion-
Need: a pair of jeans for work
Purchase: 1 pair of Ann Taylor loft jeans, 1 pair of Levi 505 cropped jeans, 1 pair of GAP cropped jeans

Went for jeans came back with a few extra items
Total cost- $4.99 a pair, roughly $15 total